Carnegie Diner & Café – 828 8th Ave, New York, NY

Reseñas de Carnegie Diner & Café – 828 8th Ave, New York, NY de comensales del restaurante. Basadas en valoraciones recientes.

1. P

   Patricia VIP

   Nueva York9 reseñas

   5.0

   Comieron hace 2 días

   1. Global 5
   2. Comida 5
   3. Servicio 5
   4. Ambiente 4

   Food terrific, service terrific. Hostess was a little bit pushing us out even though there were LOTS of empty tables and no line.
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

2. J

   Jan VIP

   San Francisco27 reseñas

   2.0

   Comieron hace 6 días

   1. Global 2
   2. Comida 2
   3. Servicio 2
   4. Ambiente 4

   Pastrami and corned beef dry and bread bordered on stale
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

3. P

   Patricia VIP

   Nueva York57 reseñas

   3.0

   Comieron hace 6 días

   1. Global 3
   2. Comida 3
   3. Servicio 4
   4. Ambiente 4

   The servers were superb doing it all, very attentive and friendly. The setting was delightful but the music loud, certainly not a Carnegie Hall vibe. Portions were large and prices a little steep but isn’t that part of the experience?
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

4. C

   Connie VIP

   Nueva York19 reseñas

   2.0

   Comieron hace 6 días

   1. Global 2
   2. Comida 3
   3. Servicio 2
   4. Ambiente 2

   I hve gone about 6 times in hopes that they have improved their service. Very slow service observed.. Our drinks were totally different from what we ordered and the plates they set down for our food were chipped badly !! Three different servers waited on us and they said it was because of shift changes at 5 o'clock happen. Who wld have shift changes at a time when theater is getting out?? All in all it was chaos all around. Won't be going back again!!!
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

5. L

   Lisa

   Charlotte10 reseñas

   4.0

   Comieron hace 6 días

   1. Global 4
   2. Comida 4
   3. Servicio 3
   4. Ambiente 3

   Lunch time is VERY BUSY, even with reservations. I had to wait for 20 minutes for a table.
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

6. P

   Paul VIP

   Nueva York52 reseñas

   4.0

   Comieron hace 7 días

   1. Global 4
   2. Comida 5
   3. Servicio 5
   4. Ambiente 3

   Excellent location, particularly if you have the tickets. Service is very quick and efficient. The only negative I can provide, and most people would consider it a positive, is the proportions are too large. 
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

7. S

   Susan VIP

   Gran Boston23 reseñas

   2.0

   Comieron hace 7 días

   1. Global 2
   2. Comida 1
   3. Servicio 2
   4. Ambiente 3

   We we seated outside. The service was sporadic. My chicken was burnt. Overall, very disappointed!!
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

8. K

   Karissa

   Nueva York1 reseña

   5.0

   Comieron hace 7 días

   1. Global 5
   2. Comida 5
   3. Servicio 5
   4. Ambiente 5

   The pork chop, Brussels sprouts and potatoes are the best I’ve ever had! Carnegie Diner doesn’t disappoint!!
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

9. C

   Cassandra

   Washington DC3 reseñas

   5.0

   Comieron en 21 de abril de 2025

   1. Global 5
   2. Comida 5
   3. Servicio 5
   4. Ambiente 4

   We had a fantastic waiter who was very attentive and helpful! Food was very good. The only complaint is the music was very loud.
   

   ¿Te fue útil?

10. D

    Donna

    Gran Boston4 reseñas

    2.0

    Comieron en 21 de abril de 2025

    1. Global 2
    2. Comida 2
    3. Servicio 2
    4. Ambiente 3

    I know it is not the original Carnegie Deli and no affiliation, however, based on reviews and being in NYC, I thought the pastrami and corned beef would be better. It was tender, but tasteless and disappointing. I was hungry so I ate it, but we won’t be back. Sorry.
    

    ¿Te fue útil?