Best Historic Restaurants in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

Food was fantastic! The ambiance is a very intimate setting. Our server was the best. Second Tuesday in a row. We love it here.

Incredible evening at Mister A’s. The Chablis was crisp, the duck was rich and tender, and the pommes aligot were silky perfection. Flawless service, breathtaking views, and a surprise chocolate fondant paired with a glass of Quinta port made it all unforgettable.

Fantastic Service Fantastic Food Fantastic Atmosphere Great Overall Food Experience

Seneca San Diego is a true gem. From the moment you walk in, the design takes your breath away! Stylish, vibrant, and full of character, with stunning views that elevate the entire experience. The food is absolutely delicious, thoughtfully prepared and beautifully presented. Service is attentive and friendly without being intrusive. The ambience strikes a perfect balance between lively and relaxed, making it ideal for both special occasions and a memorable night out. Highly recommend!

Loved everything from the food to the ambiance and costumer service!