About New York Prime Steakhouse - Myrtle Beach
Golf Magazine’s choice for “where to eat with your clients” and “best steakhouse” by The Myrtle Beach Herald. New York Prime’s menu features USDA prime for every steak such as the monster 40oz. Porterhouse for two, colossal Baked Shrimp and fresh Florida Stone Crabs. The only all-prime experience on the Grand Strand, New York Prime Steakhouse offers an extensive wine list and seating for large parties.
Steakhouse, American, Wine Bar
Hours of Operation:
Dinner: Sunday - Thursday: 5:00pm - 10:00pm, Friday - Saturday: 5:00pm - 11:00pm
Between Highway 17 and the Ocean
$31 to $50
AMEX, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Complimentary valet available.
Banquet/Private Rooms, Bar Dining, Bar/Lounge, Beer, Full Bar, Personal wines welcome, Personal wines welcome (corkage fee applies), Private Room, Smoking Area, Smoking Area (bar only), Takeout, Wheelchair Access, Wine, Wine Bar
Special Events & Promotions:
Book your private luncheon Monday through Friday from 11:30am to 2:30pm. Offering exclusive access to the entire restaurant with 3 prix fixe menus that will accommodate a minimum of 25 guests. There are no room fees charged.
Our new private dining room offers individual or community-style table options for up to 35 guests. Offering our full dinner menu and 4 prix fixe menus to accommodate a minimum of 25 guests. Exclusive access to the main dining room is also available for luncheons from 11:30 a.m. No room fees.
New York Prime Steakhouse - Myrtle Beach Ratings and Reviews
The best steaks around
I've been to many great steakhouses in my life and NY Prime always ranks as one of my favorites. Anytime I'm in Myrtle Beach I always try to make it a point to dine at NYP. The service is always excellent as well as the food and wine. It's a not miss for me.
Great food !
Great food !
First class food and service
Multiple return visits and the standard never falters. Great steaks and and excellent service. Wine list very good but not cheap. Value depends on you.
We've been here twice over years and both times the food was very good and the service was great!
been here many times and always outstanding.
Robert was awesome and truly was there to please!!!
First time New York prime was fantastic went for my birthday and could have been happier, food was amazing, service was fantastic. Would go back for sure
Strip steak had grizzle down the middle. Shrimp appetizer was overcooked. Would have sent it back but we were with friends. And the asparagus was way overpriced! We are locals and have seen a decline in some of the food. For,the price, everything should have been cooked to,perfection and nothing should have been overcooked. Could have gotten a better steak at Ruth's Chris.
Expected great but got good! Definitely ...
Expected great but got good! Definitely overpriced for the experience. Service was the highlight. Manhattan prices in MB. Now see why they call it NY Prime.
The food is always awesome, been going f ...
The food is always awesome, been going for years. The noise level gets a little annoying at times. Lots of people come in after a day of golf and they seem to forget others are enjoying meals and conversation of their own. Food and service are amazing!!! So I will continue to go!
The food was delicious and well worth th ...
The food was delicious and well worth the trip. I plan to come back again without a doubt.
Expensive BURNT Steak
We spent $325 for burnt steak and tasteless food. The service was excellent, however that doesn't overpower the expectation that our food should have tasted amazing, instead of being overwhelmed by a burnt taste. Read up on "Philadelphia style" steak prior to going to NY Prime to avoid a large dissapointment. I'm from Kansas City and know what a juicy, not burnt, medium rare steak should taste like, and this certainly wasn't it.
Been several times however this time very disappointed, extremely loud and food not up to standard of high end dinning !
Great all around!
Great all around!
I visit NYP just about every time I get to MB. The food is outstanding the bar staff and servers are friendly and prompt.
Jessie and Bruno are excellent waiters and worth asking for when dining there. It's hard to find such fine service plus the Steaks and Lobster (3lbs and up) are just wonderful!
Best steak I have ever put to my lips. W ...
Best steak I have ever put to my lips. We have traveled all over the United States, and never had a better steak then at New York prime. Service is top notch.
Still taste the delicious food - 5 days later!
WE RECEIVED A GIFT CERTIFICATE FROM OUR FAMILY FOR OUR ANNIVERSARY. WE DECIDED TO GO ON EASTER AND WERE VERY PLEASED WITH EVERYTHING. FOOD, SERVICE, ATMOSPHERE --- EVERYTHING WAS 5 STAR!
Amazing services and delicious food!
Amazing services and delicious food!
Classic New York Steak House
If you are looking for a classic New York Steak House experience this is Myrtle Beach best. The entre meat was superior and both our steaks were cooked to perfection. The sides were "average" when you consider the cost. The starters were also not up to the quality you would expect for the price. Our service was exceptional in the beginning, but became much less attentitive as tables of 4 and 6 filled up in the servers territory. The unique NY steakhouse atmosphere became bothersome as the resturant and bar filled up. It became noisy and crowded to the point of being uncomfortable. This is not an experience we would recommend for everyday dinning, save this one for very special occasions.
Another wonderful experience
Once again we had a great dinner and great service at NY Prime. Crab cocktail and romulade the best anywhere in the world. My raw NY steak aged to perfection. Wife's delmonico great as well. Will be back in the fall when we return!
A wonderful place to dine. Our server, S ...
A wonderful place to dine. Our server, Stephan, went above and beyond for us. We didn't feel rushed, enjoyed the classic music. We started with Stone Crab. A bit pricy but delicious. Then we had a filet, aged and cooked to perfection. The baked potato was delicious as well. Treat yourself to this amazing place.
Good but not as good as past visits
Food was very good but prior visits the food was fantastic Cigar smoke from bar patrons was bad much better after complaints and they finally turned on the smoke eaters Service was fantastic as usual
golf shopping trip
Delicious food, very good service, only issue very noisy. Can,t beat the food, steaks are excellant.
Great food and great service! The ambia ...
Great food and great service! The ambiance is unique to Myrtle Beach. Save room for the white chocolate banana cream pie!!
NY Prime is always excellent in every way but absolutely love to go when stone crabs are in season. Make sure to stop by the bar for an adult beverage and "fried peanuts"
Excellent food, excellent service.
My husband and I started coming here when restaurant open, we have never been disappointed in either the service or food. The service is outstanding .
Late Valentines dinner
My wife and I celebrated a late Valentines weekend at the beach topped with a nice dinner. Was my third time dining at NY Prime and as usual, food and service was excellent! My wife does not eat seafood so as an appetizer we ordered the bacon. Was not sure what it would be like but wow!! Really great. Followed up with a filet and cheesey potatoes, doesn't get much better.
the food and service was excellent. I f ...
the food and service was excellent. I found the amount of noise noteworthy
The steaks here are the best you will ever eat. The cheesecake from Carnge Dellie is legendary. The bill is stiff, but worth every cent.
The waiter was awesome, & the hostess to ...
The waiter was awesome, & the hostess took our coats. Nice touch!
Best in Myrtle Beach
I'm from the NY area, and usually don't go to restaurants outside the area using New York in their name. However, New York Prime is the best steakhouse in the Myrtle Beach area, and definitely reminds me of some of New York's best as well.
The food was excellent for the most part.
My only issue was I thought the mushrooms could have been sauteed a little longer. Everything else was very good, especially the prime cut. prepared perfectly.
NY Prime, the best steakhouse in the southeastern
If you are interested in attentive, detailed, perfect service, to serve the freshest, crispest, cold salads before you dine on award level beef cooked to perfection Ina 2,000 degree broiler or that wonderful whole Maine lobster you only get once or twice a lifetime, all served alongside perfect potatoes and crisp vegetables.....you must go to New York Prime Steakhouse. The very best Restauarnt in Myrtle Beach. Period
This was, without a doubt, the finest me ...
This was, without a doubt, the finest meal/steak I've ever had. The service was flawless and the ambiance definitely reminded me of NYC.
Another great dining experience!
From the valets to the bus boys to the wonderful waitstaff including our waiter Stefano you could not ask for better or more professional service. The food is magnificent, the drinks ample and the sides extra large. Try the creamed spinach and take the Oscar option on your steak. Except if you eat your NY steak raw like me, then just enjoy the finest steak anywhere!
very nice evening
NY Prime really has the look, feel, service, and food quality of a big city steakhouse. If you want a dining experience reflective of attentive and superior service NY Prime is for you.
Very nice staff
If my steak wasn't overlooked they would have 5 stars across the board.
Absolutely amazing food and service.
Absolutely amazing food and service.
This was our families 3rd visit with NY ...
This was our families 3rd visit with NY Prime. It has always been an excellent choice and the service and food were wonderful. Will be back.
Wife's steak terible
Wife's steak not cooked rare not medium rare wrong cut waiter stated steaks served by table and seating . Mother in laws was wife's cut, reorderd still recived same cut, requsted same cut of here mother's still recived same cut over cooked medium well. We patrons of New York Prime on our birthdays and Holidays never again or recommend. Lost customers, one happy customer tells three, one unhappy will tell thirty-three fact 3-33 rule fact! Former service manager for care dealership No. 1 in customer srevice in norhern Virginia DC metro area SERVICE IS SERVICE SAME RULES apply !!!!
Report this review as inappropriate?
If you believe this review should be removed from OpenTable, please let us know and someone will investigate.